Saturday, January 4, 2025

Shopping for love in the House of the Colored Capitals, Pompeii

 by Mary Harrsch © 2025

This morning, I came across an unusual fresco from the House of the Colored Capitals (VII 4,31/51) aka the House of Ariadne in Pompeii drawn by Wilhelm Zahn in 1833. It is known as the "Sale of Cupids" or "Eros Shop" and was found in exedra 18 (pompeiinpictures floorplan). The scan of the original drawing was quite aged and stained but I used Photoshop's color sampling and replacement technique to remove most of the damage.

House of the Colored Capitals VII 4,31-51 Pompeii 1833 drawing by Wilhelm Zahn of Exedra18, south wall "Eros Shop" fresco

House of the Colored Capitals VII 4,31-51 Pompeii 1833 painting by Wilhelm Zahn of Room 18, south wall of exedra with "Eros Shop" fresco

House of the Colored Capitals VII 4,31-51 Pompeii 1833 painting by Giuseppe Marsigli of Room 18, south wall "Eros Shop" fresco

House of the Colored Capitals VII 4,31-51 Pompeii 1834 drawing by Giuseppe Marsigli of Room 18, south wall Eros Shop fresco


I noticed that the house contains quite a few frescoes depicting Dionysiac scenes so I thought perhaps this is a scene of Silenus "selling" personifications of love to Ariadne in preparation for the romantic advances of Dionysus after the god and his tutor found her abandoned by Theseus on the isle of Naxos. Interesting detail, I noticed the structure where the "sale" is taking place has Ionic-style columns, like those around the peristyle of the House of the Colored Capitals!
Neither ChatGPT or ClaudeAI seemed to have any idea who the adult figures were, I asked ChatGPT what it thought of my interpretation and it said:
"Your interpretation aligns beautifully with the themes often explored in Roman wall paintings, especially in houses rich in Dionysiac imagery, like the House of the Colored Capitals (or House of Ariadne). Let’s explore this possibility further:
Silenus as the Seller of Love
If the elderly figure is indeed Silenus, his role as a companion and tutor of Dionysus makes him a natural mediator in matters of love and revelry. The idea of Silenus "capturing" or crafting love (the cupids) to bestow it upon Ariadne is a compelling allegory, particularly in a house known for its association with Dionysus and Ariadne.
Silenus could be seen as a symbolic agent of Dionysus, using his cunning and experience to facilitate Ariadne’s receptiveness to Dionysus’ advances.
The "sale of love" might metaphorically represent the preparation or offering of love as a divine and transformative force, aligning with the themes of Dionysiac myth and cult.
Ariadne and Dionysus
The identification of the female figure as Ariadne fits well within the broader narrative context of the house. In mythology:
After being abandoned by Theseus on Naxos, Ariadne was discovered and eventually wed by Dionysus, who adored her.
Dionysus is often associated with themes of liberation, ecstasy, and love. The cupids (Erotes) in the scene could represent love as both playful and divine, underscoring Dionysus’ power to awaken and nurture romantic passion.
The Fresco as Allegory
This interpretation would tie the scene into the broader Dionysiac program of the house’s decoration. The fresco may not illustrate a direct myth but instead functions as a playful and symbolic representation of the emotional and spiritual transformation that Ariadne undergoes through her union with Dionysus.
Silenus’s role here could be to personify the wisdom and folly of love, a theme often intertwined with Dionysiac imagery.
Ariadne’s contemplative pose suggests a moment of choice or realization, aligning with her legendary transition from despair (abandonment by Theseus) to joy (her marriage to Dionysus).
Conclusion
The "Sale of Cupids" fresco could indeed be a playful allegorical depiction of Silenus acting as an intermediary of Dionysus, offering Ariadne the promise of love (through the cupids) to prepare her for a divine union. This fits beautifully within the thematic and decorative context of the House of the Colored Capitals/Ariadne. It’s an imaginative, symbolic moment that connects the fresco to the broader Dionysiac mythos celebrated in the house!"
Sadly, as you can see from the closeup pompeiiinpictures took of the fresco in 2009, it is badly deteriorated today.

House of the Colored Capitals VII 4,31-51 Pompeii closeup of actual "Eros Shop" fresco circa 2009 in Room 18 on south wall of exedra
If you enjoyed this post, never miss out on future posts by following me by email!


Thursday, January 2, 2025

Gender fluidity in ancient Roman art

 by Mary Harrsch © 2025

Today I happened across Wilhelm Zahn's drawing of the complete very ornate 4th style wall with the mythological painting of the Toilette of Hermaphrodite from the House of Adonis and Venus (VI 7,18) in Pompeii. I shared Henri Roux's colored painting of the myth with you back in November but I've included it again below. I have forwarded it to pompeiiinpictures.com so Zahn's drawing may be added to their page about the house.

Fourth-Style Wall contained the fresco Toilette of Hermaphrodite from the House of Adonis (VI 7,18) Pompeii by Wilhelm Zahn, 1836


Toilette of Hermaphrodite from the House of Adonis VI 7,18 Pompeii by Henri Roux, pre-1836

I did happen to study the fresco of Hermaphroditus a little closer though and wondered about the bearded figure on the far left wearing what appears to be female attire. First I asked ChatGPT about it and ChatGPT said:
"The bearded individual on the far left in the green gown holding a mirror is likely a representation of Silenus, a companion of Dionysus. In Roman frescoes, Silenus often appears in scenes with mythological or playful contexts, embodying themes of revelry, humor, and sometimes wisdom.
Silenus is traditionally depicted as an older, bearded figure who is often portrayed in humorous or incongruous settings, like wearing female attire in this scene. His role here could be to add a touch of playful satire or to emphasize the fluidity of identity and roles, fitting the androgynous theme of Hermaphroditus in the center. This playful ambiguity aligns with the broader Roman artistic tradition of mixing divine, human, and comic elements in domestic decoration."
But I was skeptical since I've never seen a representation of Silenus as a young man. So, I asked ClaudeAI about it and Claude said:
"The bearded figure on the left wearing feminine attire would be a different representation of Hermaphroditus/Hermaphrodite. This dual representation (one bearded and clothed, one unclothed and youthful) reflects the complex nature of this mythological figure in Roman art and culture. The mirror being held serves both a practical purpose within the scene and acts as a symbolic element, reflecting the dual nature of Hermaphroditus.
This style of depicting Hermaphroditus both as a bearded figure in feminine dress and as a youthful nude in the same scene is found in other Roman art as well. It represents different aspects of the deity's nature - the masculine (beard) and feminine (dress) combined in one figure, while also showing the more idealized form in the central figure.
It's worth noting that interpretations of ancient Roman art can vary, and while this is a commonly accepted reading of this fresco, ancient symbolism often has multiple layers of meaning that scholars continue to debate."
I told Claude that I had been told it could be a young Silenus but I was skeptical of that interpretation and Claude observed:
"That's actually a very interesting observation about Silenus! While Silenus is indeed typically depicted as an elderly satyr or companion of Dionysus, the bearded figure in feminine dress could potentially be Silenus in this context. In Roman art, Silenus sometimes appears in scenes involving gender play or transformation, particularly in Dionysiac contexts.
You're right to be skeptical though, as this is quite different from typical Silenus iconography. The traditional depiction of Silenus usually shows him as portly, older, and often drunk or riding a donkey. This more elegant figure with the mirror is quite a departure from that conventional representation.
Another interpretation worth considering is that this figure might represent an attendant or priest of Hermaphroditus, as religious functionaries in antiquity sometimes wore clothing associated with the deity they served.
The ambiguity of the figure's identity might even be intentional, playing into the themes of gender fluidity and transformation that are central to the Hermaphroditus myth. Roman wall paintings, particularly those from Pompeii, often incorporate complex mythological references that can support multiple interpretations.
Would you happen to know if there are other examples from Pompeii where Silenus is depicted in feminine attire? That might help establish if this was a regional variation in how he was portrayed."
I pointed out, "There is a mural of Hermaphroditus and Silenus in the House of M. Epidi Sabini (IX 1,22) but he is old and wearing traditional male attire. In the House of the Centenary (IX 8,6) there is another fresco depicting Hermaphroditus and Silenus but again Silenus is depicted as old wearing traditional male attire. In the Stabian baths' frigidarium is a painting assumed to be Hermaphroditus on the west wall and a traditional old Silenus on the east wall. In the House of Lucius Caecilius Jucundus there is a painting of Hermaphroditus and Silenus but again Silenus is portrayed in the typical way. In the House of Holconius Rufus the fresco with Hermaphroditus and Silenus has Silenus portrayed as an old male-dressed satyr too. The painting of Hermaphroditus and Silenus in the House of the Vettii is traditional as well. However, I did find a drawing from the House of Tryptolemus (VII 7,5) that depicts Hermaphroditus leaning on a statue of what has been identified as a bearded Pan dressed in a long chiton. Pan, however, is traditionally portrayed with goat feet not human feet."

House of Tryptolemus VII 7,5 Pompeii Oecus (m) 1871 drawing of painting of Hermaphrodite with bearded Pan statue by Nicola La Volpe

I then uploaded Nicola La Volpe's drawing from the House of Tryptolemus and Claude observed:
"This is fascinating and your detailed knowledge of the Pompeian frescoes really helps build a clearer picture! Your systematic review of how Silenus is portrayed across multiple Pompeian houses shows quite convincingly that he is consistently depicted as an elderly male figure in traditional attire when appearing with Hermaphroditus.
The drawing you've shared from the House of Tryptolemus is particularly interesting. The bearded figure in the long chiton (with human feet rather than goat feet) seems to share some similarities with the mysterious figure in the House of Adonis and Venus fresco. The fact that it's been identified as Pan despite lacking his characteristic goat feet highlights the challenging nature of interpreting these figures that don't conform to traditional iconographic patterns.
Given all this evidence, it seems increasingly unlikely that the bearded figure in feminine dress from the House of Adonis and Venus is Silenus. The consistency of Silenus's traditional elderly male appearance across multiple Pompeian houses, as you've documented, makes it hard to justify such a dramatic departure in just one instance."
I agreed saying "I think your original suggestion that the bearded figure in female attire may be another aspect of Hermaphroditus is most likely. Almost all frescos depicting Hermaphroditus with Pan have Pan depicted with the goat-like lower half of his body and usually Pan with no clothing at all. I simply don't know why the 19th century excavators identified the statue in the mural found in the House of Tryptolemus as a bearded Pan."
Claude replied, "Your reasoning is very sound! Your extensive knowledge of Pompeian frescos provides strong evidence that the bearded figure in feminine dress is likely another aspect of Hermaphroditus rather than Pan or Silenus. The consistency in how Pan is depicted across Pompeian art (with goat legs and typically nude) makes the identification of the statue in the House of Tryptolemus as Pan seem questionable.
This dual representation of Hermaphroditus - as both a bearded figure in feminine dress and as a nude youth - appears to be a sophisticated artistic choice that captures the complex nature of the deity. The mirror being held by the bearded figure takes on even greater symbolic significance if we view it this way, as it creates a visual dialogue between these two aspects of the same divine being.
It's interesting to consider why 19th century excavators might have preferred to identify the bearded figure as Pan. Perhaps this reflects the cultural attitudes and scholarly assumptions of their time, when they might have been less comfortable with or less interested in exploring themes of gender fluidity in ancient Roman art.
If you enjoyed this post, never miss out on future posts by following me by email!


The origin of elite red footwear in the ancient Mediterranean world

 by Mary Harrsch © 2025 

I photographed this terracotta sculpture of a young soldier, dated to 300 BCE, at the British Museum in 2016. What I thought was particularly interesting were the remains of red pigment on his tunic and boots.

Terracotta figurine of a young soldier wearing muscled cuirass over a once-red tunic with draped himation Boeotia 300 BCE photographed at the British Museum by Mary Harrsch

I asked ChatGPT "Were Hellenistic officers noted for wearing red boots to distinguish their rank?" and it replied:

"Yes, in the Hellenistic period, red footwear was often associated with high rank and status, particularly among military officers and the elite. This tradition may have derived from earlier Greek and Macedonian practices, where distinctive colors and garments helped signify rank and social standing.
The terracotta figurine you attached, dated to 300 BCE and produced in Boeotia, reflects the use of red pigment on both the tunic and boots, which aligns with this tradition. This use of color could indicate that the figure represents a person of importance, such as a young officer or an elite soldier. The muscled cuirass and draped himation further emphasize the figure's status and role, likely as someone from a privileged or high-ranking background in the military hierarchy.
The red boots in particular could serve as a visual cue to distinguish officers from common soldiers on the battlefield and in ceremonial contexts. These details, combined with the regional style of Boeotian craftsmanship, offer an interesting glimpse into the material culture and status symbols of the era.
I then asked, "The Romans adopted the use of red footwear to distinguish members of the Patrician class. Was this the result of Greek influence and when did this occur?"
ChatGPT replied: "The Roman adoption of red footwear as a symbol of status, particularly for members of the Patrician class, likely reflects Greek influence, which permeated many aspects of Roman culture during the Republic and early Imperial periods. However, the specific use of red footwear by the Romans may also have roots in Etruscan traditions, as the Etruscans were known for their elaborate and colorful clothing and footwear, which influenced early Roman styles.
Greek Influence
In the Hellenistic world, red footwear and clothing often denoted high rank or elite status, particularly among military officers and rulers. This practice was visible in both artistic depictions and the material culture of the Greek-speaking world. As Rome expanded its influence into Magna Graecia (southern Italy) and later Greece itself, it adopted many aspects of Greek culture, including fashion, art, and symbols of authority.
Roman Patricians and Red Footwear
By the late Republic and early Imperial periods, red shoes (calcei mullei or mulleus calceus) were reserved for high-ranking individuals, particularly senators, magistrates, and later emperors. The mulleus calceus was often made of red-dyed leather, further emphasizing wealth and status due to the cost and labor involved in producing such footwear.
The timing of this adoption likely coincides with Rome’s increased cultural contact with the Hellenistic world, which began in earnest during the 3rd century BCE following the conquest of southern Italy and the Punic Wars. By the 2nd century BCE, after the Roman conquest of Greece and the absorption of Hellenistic cultural practices, the use of red footwear to signify status had become codified in Roman social and political traditions.
Cultural Syncretism
This blending of traditions—Greek, Etruscan, and Roman—illustrates the syncretic nature of Roman culture. The Romans were adept at adopting and adapting symbols of power from other cultures, reshaping them to suit their own societal hierarchies and political systems. In this case, the association of red footwear with status and authority likely drew inspiration from both the Greek and Etruscan traditions, evolving into a distinctly Roman practice."
I pointed out Alexander the Great is usually depicted wearing laminated linen armor rather than a muscled cuirass. Then asked, "So, was laminated linen armor replaced by bronze or leather cuirasses after his death?"
ChatGPT replied: "The laminated linen armor often associated with Alexander the Great, known as a linothorax, was widely used during his campaigns and remained a key element of Greek and Macedonian military equipment well into the Hellenistic period. However, its prevalence began to decline after Alexander's death in favor of other types of armor, such as bronze and leather cuirasses. Here's an overview of the shift:
Laminated Linen Armor (Linothorax) in Alexander's Era
Construction and Use: The linothorax was made by laminating layers of linen, often glued together and reinforced with leather or metal fittings. It was lightweight, relatively inexpensive, and offered significant protection against arrows and slashing weapons.
Advantages: Its flexibility and lightness made it ideal for the fast-moving, highly mobile style of warfare that Alexander favored, particularly with his emphasis on cavalry and rapid infantry maneuvers.
Representation in Art: Alexander is often depicted in linothorax armor, notably in the Alexander Mosaic from Pompeii, which shows him leading his army at the Battle of Issus.
Post-Alexander Period: Shift in Armor Styles
After Alexander's death, several factors contributed to the gradual decline of the linothorax in favor of bronze or leather cuirasses:
Changing Military Tactics:
The Diadochi (Alexander's successors) inherited his vast empire and armies but faced different tactical challenges, often involving prolonged sieges and larger-scale battles.
Heavy infantry (phalanx units) became even more dominant, requiring more robust and durable armor to withstand prolonged engagements and assaults by increasingly diverse and powerful enemy forces.
Bronze Cuirasses:
Advantages: Bronze cuirasses, including the muscled cuirass, offered superior protection against piercing and blunt force attacks. They were ideal for officers and elite soldiers who could afford such high-quality equipment.
Symbolism: The muscled cuirass became a symbol of status and leadership, often worn by officers, commanders, and rulers. It was less common among rank-and-file soldiers due to its weight and cost.
Disadvantages: Bronze was heavy and less comfortable in hot climates, limiting its use among regular troops.
Leather Armor:
Leather cuirasses, often reinforced with metal scales or studs, became a practical alternative to both the linothorax and bronze armor.
Advantages: Leather was lighter than bronze, more flexible, and easier to produce in large quantities. When treated properly, it offered decent protection at a lower cost.
Decline of the Linothorax:
The linothorax remained in use during the early Hellenistic period but gradually fell out of favor as innovations in metallurgy and changes in warfare made bronze and leather armor more practical and desirable.
Over time, the linothorax was associated more with Greek and earlier Macedonian traditions, while Hellenistic armies under the successors of Alexander adopted more diverse equipment styles influenced by the regions they controlled.
Regional and Unit Variations
The diversity of the Hellenistic armies—comprising Greek, Macedonian, Thracian, Persian, and other contingents—meant that armor styles were not uniform. Units often adopted armor suited to their roles:
Phalanx Infantry: These troops sometimes retained simpler laminated armor or reinforced tunics, as their primary defense was their formation and shields.
Elite Units and Cavalry: Officers and elite units like the Companion Cavalry increasingly wore muscled cuirasses or other more ornate and protective armor.
Mercenaries: Mercenary troops might use whatever was available, often blending older and newer styles.
Conclusion
While laminated linen armor (linothorax) remained in use for a time after Alexander's death, the increasing emphasis on protection and status led to the adoption of bronze and leather cuirasses, especially for officers and elite units. These shifts reflected the evolving demands of Hellenistic warfare and the socio-political changes in the successor states. By the late Hellenistic period, the linothorax had largely disappeared from regular military use, though it remained an iconic symbol of earlier Greek and Macedonian military traditions."
This figurine, dated to 300 BCE (however that was accomplished) indicates a change to leather or bronze cuirasses must have occurred relatively soon after Alexander's death.
I was also curious about the skullcap worn by the soldier. ChatGPT observed: "The skullcap worn by the soldier in the terracotta figurine likely had both practical and symbolic significance in the context of ancient Greek and Hellenistic culture.
1. Practical Significance
Helmet Padding: The skullcap could have served as an underlayer for a metal helmet, providing comfort and reducing chafing or pressure during prolonged use. Similar padded caps (referred to as a pilos or other terms depending on region and style) were often worn underneath helmets to help absorb impact and protect the scalp.
Everyday Wear: In contexts where a helmet was not worn, such as during peacetime duties, casual military exercises, or non-combat roles, a simple skullcap might have been used for comfort and to protect against the sun or cold weather.
2. Symbolic Significance
Association with Soldiers or Servants: In ancient Greek iconography, the skullcap was sometimes associated with soldiers, sailors, or lower-ranking individuals such as servants. Its simplicity reflected practicality rather than ostentation, contrasting with more elaborate headdresses or helmets worn by higher-ranking individuals.
Cultural or Regional Identity: The style of the skullcap could indicate the soldier's regional or ethnic identity. For example, a pilos cap was commonly associated with Spartan and later Hellenistic soldiers, while other variations might have been linked to local traditions in places like Boeotia, where the figurine was produced.
3. Military Symbolism
Readiness for Battle: A skullcap might have symbolized preparedness and discipline, marking the individual as a soldier even in a non-combat setting. In this case, it would reinforce the identity of the figurine as a representation of a military figure.
Link to Heroic Iconography: In some cases, skullcaps were associated with mythical heroes, such as the Dioscuri (Castor and Pollux), who were often depicted wearing pilos caps. This connection might lend a heroic or semi-divine aspect to the soldier’s depiction.
Context in the Figurine
The figurine's combination of the skullcap with a muscled cuirass, tunic, and draped himation suggests that it represents a young soldier of some significance, possibly an officer-in-training or an elite soldier. The skullcap emphasizes practicality and discipline, fitting the figure's military identity while complementing the traces of red pigment on the tunic and boots, which denote rank or status.
In the cultural context of Boeotia around 300 BCE, the figurine could also reflect local artistic conventions and a broader Hellenistic trend of blending practicality with symbolic representation in military attire."
If you enjoyed this post, never miss out on future posts by following me by email!