by Mary Harrsch © 2025
While I was at the British Museum in 2016, I also photographed this beautiful bronze handle that is said to depict a nereid mounted on a hippocamp carrying Achilles' cuirass across the sea. Since I have seen a number of Roman frescoes depicting Hephaestus showing Achilles' armor to Thetis, his nereid mother, I wondered why the museum did not identify this piece as depicting Thetis.
 |
| Repousee relief of a nereid mounted on a hippocamp carrying Achilles' cuirass across the see dated to about 350 BCE. Photographed at the British Museum by Mary Harrsch. |
ChatGPT said: "The female figure on the bronze handle is identified as a nereid rather than Thetis because nereids, as a collective group of sea nymphs, were often depicted as attendants in mythological scenes related to Achilles’ armor. While Thetis was a nereid herself, classical art frequently represented her alongside or as part of a group of nereids when conveying the transportation of Achilles' divine armor.
Key reasons for the identification as a general nereid rather than Thetis include:
Artistic Tradition: In Greek and later Roman art, nereids were commonly shown carrying Achilles' armor across the sea, either riding hippocamps (mythical sea horses) or dolphins. While Thetis was responsible for securing the armor from Hephaestus, the delivery was often depicted as a group effort by the nereids.
Lack of Specific Attributes: If the figure were explicitly meant to represent Thetis, she might bear attributes distinguishing her from ordinary nereids, such as a more regal posture, a crown, or a more central placement in the composition. The absence of these features suggests that the artist intended a more generic nereid representation.
Function of the Object: The relief decorates a utilitarian object, likely a vessel or a piece of furniture, where mythological scenes were often generalized rather than strictly adhering to literary specificity. This suggests an emphasis on visual themes rather than precise narrative accuracy.
Common Iconography: Thetis is sometimes shown more solemnly in depictions of Achilles' fate, whereas nereids are often portrayed dynamically, as seen in this piece, energetically transporting the divine armor.
The identification, therefore, likely stems from established artistic conventions that favored nereids as the bearers of Achilles’ armor, unless a work explicitly emphasized Thetis' central role."
I pointed out The piece is dated to 350 BCE. then asked, "Is this a fairly common decoration during this period?"
"Yes, this type of decoration was fairly common in the 4th century BCE. During this period, bronze appliqués and handles with mythological relief scenes were widely used on vessels, furniture, and other decorative objects.
Context of the Decoration:
Greek Decorative Bronze Work: The late Classical period (ca. 400–323 BCE) saw an increased production of elaborately decorated bronze vessels and furniture fittings, often featuring repoussé reliefs with mythological themes. These items were produced in workshops across Greece and Magna Graecia (southern Italy), sometimes for export.
Nereids and Maritime Themes: Scenes featuring nereids riding hippocamps, dolphins, or sea creatures were a popular motif in Greek art, especially in contexts related to funerary and sympotic (banquet) vessels. The connection between nereids and Achilles’ divine armor also made this a favored mythological theme.
Function and Style: Bronze handles and appliqués like this one were used to adorn high-status objects, such as kraters (large mixing vessels for wine), hydriai (water jars), or chests. The relief work demonstrates the skilled metalworking techniques of the period, including repoussé (hammered relief) and engraving.
Comparison to Other Artifacts: Similar nereid scenes appear on red-figure pottery, funerary reliefs, and even painted tomb decorations, especially in South Italian and Macedonian contexts. The motif was also popular in Hellenistic art and continued into Roman times, appearing on sarcophagi and silverware.
Conclusion: This type of decoration was quite common in the late Classical period. It reflects both the artistic trends of the time and the widespread appeal of mythological imagery, particularly scenes related to Achilles and the sea, which had connotations of heroism, divine favor, and possibly an association with the afterlife."
Since ChatGPT mentioned this theme was found on red-figure ceramics, I checked for pottery with this theme in the collections of the British Museum and found a red-figured bell krater with a similar scene depicting Thetis on a hippocamp accompanied by two other nereids, one on a dolphin and one on a Keto-like sea monster, all carrying pieces of Achilles armor.
 |
| Red-figured bell krater with scene of Thetis mounted on a hippocoamp carrying Achilles' shield accompanied by two nereids, one mounted on a dolphin and the other mounted on a Keto-like sea monster also carrying parts of Achilles' armor. Image courtesy of the British Museum. |
All of the female figures were fully clothed and the figure identified as Thetis was particularly elaborately dressed. I uploaded a copy of the image of the bell krater to ChatGPT and it observed:
"That Attic red-figure bell krater you found is a valuable point of comparison for the bronze handle. Since it securely identifies Thetis as elaborately dressed while mounted on a hippocamp, it reinforces the argument that the partially nude figure on the bronze handle is more likely a generic nereid rather than Thetis.
Key Observations from the Krater:
Thetis wears a richly detailed garment while carrying Achilles’ shield, in line with more traditional portrayals of her as a dignified maternal figure.
She is accompanied by nereids, who are sometimes depicted with more fluid or revealing drapery, distinguishing them from Thetis.
The scene follows an established iconographic tradition of nereids transporting Achilles' armor, which appears frequently in 4th-century BCE Greek and South Italian art.
Implications for the Bronze Handle:
If the krater follows the Attic tradition of portraying Thetis fully draped, the bronze handle—if also Attic—would likely follow similar conventions.
The bronze handle’s partially nude figure aligns more with nereid representations from this period, particularly in Magna Graecia, where nereids were often depicted riding sea creatures.
The lack of clear attributes distinguishing Thetis (such as an elaborate garment or a more stately posture) on the handle makes a nereid identification more plausible.
Conclusion: "Given that Thetis remains fully draped in the krater’s depiction, it suggests that 4th-century BCE Attic artists maintained a conventional, dignified portrayal of her. If the bronze handle were also Attic, we would expect Thetis to be clothed in a similar manner. Since the figure is partially nude, it is more consistent with nereid iconography. This strengthens the argument that the bronze handle depicts a nereid, rather than Thetis herself, transporting Achilles’ armor."
I then asked if Thetis is ever portrayed partially nude in 4th century BCE Greek art and ChatGPT said:
"Yes, Thetis was occasionally portrayed partially nude in 4th-century BCE art, though it was not the most common representation. The increasing naturalism and sensuality in late Classical Greek art led to more dynamic and revealing portrayals of mythological figures, including nereids and, by extension, Thetis.
Evidence from 4th-Century BCE Art
South Italian Red-Figure Pottery (Magna Graecia, ca. 350–300 BCE)
Some vases from this period depict Thetis with flowing drapery that partially reveals her torso, similar to how nereids are portrayed.
A well-known example is the Apulian volute kraters, where Thetis appears among nereids bringing Achilles’ armor, sometimes with exposed shoulders or arms, suggesting movement and divine grace.
Bronze and Terracotta Reliefs
Decorative appliqués and reliefs, such as those used on furniture and vessels, sometimes depict nereids carrying Achilles’ armor in an energetic and semi-nude fashion.
Given that your bronze handle dates to ca. 350 BCE and features a nereid riding a hippocamp, it fits within this artistic trend. If Thetis were meant to be identified, she would likely be portrayed similarly to other nereids, possibly with exposed arms, shoulders, or upper torso.
Influence of Praxitelean Style
The 4th century BCE saw a shift in artistic conventions, particularly under the influence of sculptors like Praxiteles, who introduced a more sensual, naturalistic approach to depicting gods and nymphs.
While Thetis was not as commonly depicted as Aphrodite, nereids associated with her were increasingly shown with wet, clinging drapery or partially nude forms.
Conclusion: While Thetis was traditionally depicted fully draped, 4th-century BCE art, especially in Magna Graecia and decorative bronze reliefs, occasionally portrayed her in a more nereid-like, partially nude manner. This aligns with broader artistic trends emphasizing movement, fluidity, and the connection between nereids and the sea. Given these conventions, the figure on your bronze handle is more likely identified as a generic nereid rather than explicitly as Thetis."
I noticed on the red-figured bell krater Eros was present and asked if the presence of Eros pointed to the central figure being identified as Thetis. But, ChatGPT said:
Eros is not typically present in scenes depicting Thetis, making his inclusion on the bell krater an interesting artistic choice. In most representations of Thetis, especially those showing her interactions with Achilles or Hephaestus, Eros does not play a role. However, there are a few possible explanations for his presence in this specific image:
1. Association with the Sea and Nereids
Eros is sometimes depicted in marine settings, often accompanying Aphrodite or nereids.
Since nereids are linked to the sea and often associated with beauty and seduction, Eros’ presence might reinforce their connection to love, attraction, or divine favor.
2. Symbolic Meaning in Thetis’ Story
Thetis’ most famous myth involves her forced marriage to Peleus, which was orchestrated by Zeus and Poseidon due to a prophecy that her son would surpass his father. In this context, Eros represents divine influence over love and marriage, even when it is reluctant. While the krater doesn’t depict Thetis’ marriage, Eros might allude to this earlier episode in her mythology.
3. Influence of South Italian and Late Classical Aesthetics
By the 4th century BCE, especially in Magna Graecia, Eros was increasingly depicted in diverse mythological scenes, even where he had no direct literary role.
His presence may serve a more decorative or allegorical function, enhancing the graceful, elegant aesthetic of the composition rather than strictly adhering to mythological canon.
Conclusion: Eros’ presence in depictions of Thetis is unusual but not inexplicable. On the bell krater, he may be included due to:
His association with nereids and the sea,
A symbolic nod to Thetis’ past marriage,
The broader trend in 4th-century art to incorporate Eros in a wider range of scenes.
While not a standard feature in Thetis iconography, his inclusion here aligns with the evolving artistic conventions of the period."
So, I asked if Eros' presence could point to Thetis' love for her son, Achilles.
ChatGPT replied: "Yes, that’s a compelling interpretation! Eros’ presence could symbolize Thetis’ deep, protective, and arguably tragic love for Achilles rather than romantic or erotic love. In this context, Eros would not represent physical attraction but rather maternal devotion, emotional intensity, and the bond between mother and son.
Supporting Evidence for This Interpretation
Thetis’ Extreme Devotion to Achilles
Thetis is one of the most emotionally expressive mothers in Greek mythology, repeatedly intervening in Achilles’ fate.
She tries to make him immortal by dipping him in the Styx, seeks divine armor from Hephaestus, and mourns his inevitable death.
Eros as a Symbol of Different Forms of Love
While Eros is often associated with romantic love, he can also signify filial love, longing, and attachment.
In some late Classical and Hellenistic art, Eros' role broadens to represent bonds of affection, not just erotic desire.
Late Classical Artistic Trends
By the 4th century BCE, Greek art was increasingly expressive and emotionally nuanced.
Artists may have included Eros here to highlight Thetis' emotional turmoil and dedication to Achilles, emphasizing her role as a grieving mother rather than just a sea goddess delivering armor.
Conclusion: Eros' presence on the bell krater could indeed reinforce Thetis’ intense love for Achilles, rather than simply functioning as a decorative or marine motif. Given the overall pathos of Achilles’ story, this interpretation aligns well with the emotional depth often found in late Classical art."
Eros is not typically present in scenes depicting Thetis, making his inclusion on the bell krater an interesting artistic choice. In most representations of Thetis, especially those showing her interactions with Achilles or Hephaestus, Eros does not play a role. However, there are a few possible explanations for his presence in this specific image:
1. Association with the Sea and Nereids
Eros is sometimes depicted in marine settings, often accompanying Aphrodite or nereids.
Since nereids are linked to the sea and often associated with beauty and seduction, Eros’ presence might reinforce their connection to love, attraction, or divine favor.
2. Symbolic Meaning in Thetis’ Story
Thetis’ most famous myth involves her forced marriage to Peleus, which was orchestrated by Zeus and Poseidon due to a prophecy that her son would surpass his father. In this context, Eros represents divine influence over love and marriage, even when it is reluctant. While the krater doesn’t depict Thetis’ marriage, Eros might allude to this earlier episode in her mythology.
3. Influence of South Italian and Late Classical Aesthetics
By the 4th century BCE, especially in Magna Graecia, Eros was increasingly depicted in diverse mythological scenes, even where he had no direct literary role.
His presence may serve a more decorative or allegorical function, enhancing the graceful, elegant aesthetic of the composition rather than strictly adhering to mythological canon.
Conclusion: Eros’ presence in depictions of Thetis is unusual but not inexplicable. On the bell krater, he may be included due to:
His association with nereids and the sea,
A symbolic nod to Thetis’ past marriage,
The broader trend in 4th-century art to incorporate Eros in a wider range of scenes.
While not a standard feature in Thetis iconography, his inclusion here aligns with the evolving artistic conventions of the period."
So, I asked if Eros' presence could point to Thetis' love for her son, Achilles.
ChatGPT replied: "Yes, that’s a compelling interpretation! Eros’ presence could symbolize Thetis’ deep, protective, and arguably tragic love for Achilles rather than romantic or erotic love. In this context, Eros would not represent physical attraction but rather maternal devotion, emotional intensity, and the bond between mother and son.
Supporting Evidence for This Interpretation
Thetis’ Extreme Devotion to Achilles
Thetis is one of the most emotionally expressive mothers in Greek mythology, repeatedly intervening in Achilles’ fate.
She tries to make him immortal by dipping him in the Styx, seeks divine armor from Hephaestus, and mourns his inevitable death.
Eros as a Symbol of Different Forms of Love
While Eros is often associated with romantic love, he can also signify filial love, longing, and attachment.
In some late Classical and Hellenistic art, Eros' role broadens to represent bonds of affection, not just erotic desire.
Late Classical Artistic Trends
By the 4th century BCE, Greek art was increasingly expressive and emotionally nuanced.
Artists may have included Eros here to highlight Thetis' emotional turmoil and dedication to Achilles, emphasizing her role as a grieving mother rather than just a sea goddess delivering armor.
Conclusion: Eros' presence on the bell krater could indeed reinforce Thetis’ intense love for Achilles, rather than simply functioning as a decorative or marine motif. Given the overall pathos of Achilles’ story, this interpretation aligns well with the emotional depth often found in late Classical art."
Last, I asked "Would the bronze handle with a nereid carrying Achilles' cuirass have been used in a publicly accessible room or a more private room in a Greek residence?"
ChatGPT replied: "The bronze handle featuring a nereid carrying Achilles' cuirass would most likely have been used in a more publicly accessible room in a Greek residence rather than a private chamber. Here’s why:
1. Function and Placement of Decorative Bronze Fittings
Bronze handles like this were often attached to large chests (kibōtia), caskets, or furniture that stored valuable objects, possibly including armor, textiles, or other prized possessions.
Such elaborately decorated objects were commonly placed in reception rooms (androns) or symposion spaces, where elite men entertained guests.
2. Mythological Themes and Elite Display
Scenes involving Achilles, nereids, and divine armor were tied to themes of heroism, honor, and divine favor—ideal for public settings where a host could display their wealth and taste.
Greek aristocrats often curated their household decor to reflect cultural sophistication, using mythological imagery to demonstrate education and status.
3. Precedents in Symposium and Elite Furnishings
In the late Classical period (4th century BCE), luxury bronze fittings became popular on furniture and symposium-related objects.
Similar mythological bronze reliefs are found on symposium couches (klinai) and banquetware, reinforcing the idea that this handle belonged to something displayed in a shared, semi-public domestic space.
Could It Have Been in a Private Room?
While bedrooms and women’s quarters (gynaeceum) also contained chests with elaborate handles, heroic male themes like Achilles’ armor were less common in those spaces.
More intimate domestic decor often featured Dionysian or Aphrodisian themes rather than martial ones.
Conclusion
Given the subject matter and craftsmanship, the handle was likely part of an object placed in a publicly visible space, such as an andron or a household treasury area, where guests could admire it. It may have been used during symposia or displayed alongside other fine metalwork to enhance the prestige of the household."
No comments:
Post a Comment